Tax Refund Company vs Claiming Directly Through HMRC: What's the Difference?

If you suspect you have overpaid tax on work-related expenses, we look at the different ways you can claim. Use a tax refund company, or claim directly with HMRC?

Gorilla Tax Rebates

Gorilla Tax Rebates

tax refund claim options

If you suspect you have overpaid tax on work-related expenses, you might be wondering how best to claim it back. You can submit a claim directly to HMRC yourself at no cost, or you can use a professional tax refund company to manage the application for you.

While claiming directly is an option open to everyone, navigating HMRC's rules, tax codes, and paperwork on your own can quickly turn into a time-consuming and frustrating task. Understanding how both routes work helps you decide which option fits your schedule and peace of mind.


Claiming Directly Through HMRC: How It Works

Claiming tax back on your own requires dealing directly with HMRC via their online portals, postal forms, or phone lines.

The Process

  • Self-assessment or P87 forms: You must identify which form applies to your situation (such as a P87 form for employed PAYE expenses or a Self Assessment tax return for CIS workers) and fill it out manually.

  • Gathering and calculating expenses: You need to calculate exact figures for mileage, uniform allowances, subscriptions, or tools across each individual tax year going back up to four years.

  • Direct liaison with HMRC: Once submitted, you are responsible for monitoring your claim’s progress, responding to any HMRC queries, and ensuring your tax code is updated correctly.

The Trade-Off?

Claiming directly is free, but the administrative burden falls entirely on your shoulders. If you miss eligible allowances, make a calculation error, or struggle to get through to HMRC on the phone during peak hours, the process can become painstaking and drawn out.


Using a Specialist Tax Refund Company: How It Works

Using a specialist like Gorilla means handing over the administrative burden to experienced tax advisers.

The Process

  • Quick eligibility check: Start with a brief online form and a short phone call to establish your work setup and expenses.

  • Comprehensive review: A tax expert will review your income and running costs to ensure every single allowable expense (including items you might not realise you could claim for) is identified.

  • Complete claim management: Approved tax agents will then compile your paperwork, calculate your exact claim, and submit it directly to HMRC.

  • Tracking and payout: You will be assigned a dedicated account manager who monitors your claim's progress directly with HMRC, handles follow-ups, and keeps you updated until your payout is safely in your account.

[Link to detailed process blog]

The Trade-Off?

Tax refund companies charge a fee from the final rebate amount upon success. In return, you save hours of admin and gain peace of mind knowing your claim is being handled correctly by professionals.


Comparing Your Options Side-by-Side

Feature

Claiming Directly with HMRC

Claiming via Gorilla Tax Rebates

Upfront Cost

Free

Free (No Rebate, No Fee)

Admin & Paperwork

Handled entirely by you

Handled for you from start to finish

Finding Hidden Expenses

Dependent on your own tax knowledge

Checked thoroughly by specialist advisers

HMRC Progress Updates

Requires you to chase HMRC directly

Monitored by your dedicated account manager

Risk of Submission Errors

Higher if unfamiliar with HMRC rules

Minimised by HMRC-approved tax agents



Which Option Is Right for You?

If you have straightforward expenses, plenty of free time, and feel completely comfortable navigating HMRC tax systems and allowances, claiming directly is a viable route.

However, if you work long hours, want to ensure you claim every penny you are legally owed, or simply want to avoid the stress of dealing with tax paperwork and HMRC queues, using a tax refund provider such as Gorilla Tax Refunds takes the weight off your shoulders. 

We manage the entire journey on a no-rebate, no-fee basis, making reclaiming your overpaid tax fast, transparent, and completely hassle-free.

Why not start with seeing how much tax you could be owed based on your circumstances? 

Check what you’re owed >>

Related posts